Jorge Posada: Yankees Don't Want Me in The Bronx

Jorge Posada says the New York Yankees no longer want him around. The former catcher told the New York Post that he feels unwelcome when visiting the team’s facilities ^[1]. His comments stem from a recent episode of “The Show” podcast, where he discussed his potential role with the franchise. Posada stated plainly, “I don’t think they want me there to tell you the truth”.

According to ESPN, Posada clarified that he does not feel welcome even during spring training, which is why he avoids going to the facility ^[2]. This sentiment marks a stark contrast to his status as a beloved member of the “Core Four.” Posada spent his entire 17-year career with the Yankees, winning five World Series titles alongside Derek Jeter, Mariano Rivera, and Andy Pettitte.

When asked why he feels this way, Posada pointed to the difficult conclusion of his playing days in 2011. He was shifted from catcher to designated hitter and had public disagreements with the front office about his playing time. “My last season of my career was a really tough one when it comes to handling everything in my part and also the Yankees toward Jorge Posada,” he said ^[1]. He emphasized that he never had the chance to fight for his job, a point he finds hard to move past.

Posada told the New York Post that he never addressed the issues with General Manager Brian Cashman or Owner Hal Steinbrenner, though he did speak with then-manager Joe Girardi ^[1]. Cashman previously acknowledged the “rough patch” during that season, stating that everyone tried to get through it. Posada noted that he does not regret speaking out, maintaining his honest approach to the game.

Despite the tension, Posada praised current manager Aaron Boone and Cashman as the right leaders. However, he believes the players are responsible for recent postseason shortcomings. “It’s not on Boonie, it’s not on Cash,” Posada said ^[2]. He suggested the Yankees need a strong voice on the coaching staff to hold players accountable for mental mistakes. He argued that if players don’t run to first base or show effort, they should be benched. “Make him understand that this means something,” Posada said.

Since retiring, Posada has worked in the Miami Marlins front office and coached Team Italy in the World Baseball Classic. He said he enjoyed the flexibility of the Marlins role. Now, he watches from afar, noting the Yankees’ loss of Aaron Judge hurt their playoff chances. He believes the team was expected to go further. Posada remains a vocal critic, but his future with the Yankees appears uncertain.